Pine Island

FILE PHOTO
Once you cross the Matlacha Bridge into Pine Island, you will find that these islanders are not in a hurry. You’ve now become part of the largest island on the southwest Florida coastline where a community made of tight-knit neighbors waits to greet you. From the Matlacha (most “fishing-est”) Bridge in the world to the tip of Bokeelia or Saint James City, you can fish, hunt for goodies, or relax and breathe in the salt air. The Pine Island community is exceptional at making one another a priority, as neighbors look out for one another as though they are truly family. This is one of the most cherished qualities islanders confess they most love when it comes to Pine Island. Being resilient in their mission to achieve Pine Island Strong level intensity is something to which you might see, hear, come to believe in and even adhere to yourself after a short visit.
Perfect Day
Whether you are spending a day touring Pine Island and Matlacha, or even if you have come for much longer, there are a great deal of interesting things to see, learn, and do to keep you engaged. For starters, there is nothing that compares to getting your day off with a great breakfast.
Owner Rich Chalupski will welcome you to the Perfect Cup in Matlacha, where you can visit with locals over a cup of fresh coffee. Many folks from Matlacha congregate daily there, as they are open 7 days a week.
Salty Girls Island Café is another great choice, where Pine Islanders love to gather, especially since there is seating available inside the café and outdoors. Owner Lisa Dence and her friendly, efficient staff are ready to welcome you and your family and friends each morning, with fresh classic favorites, such as biscuits and gravy, or even fresh fruit if you’re eating light.
After you’ve eaten a hardy breakfast, you might want to take a trip over to the Randell Research Center, museum of natural history, in Pineland. The Calusa Heritage Trail is open daily for self-guided visits from sunrise to sunset.
If you’re a history buff, the Museum of the Islands (MOTI) has many great pieces and even cool items from here on Pine Island.
Post adventure, you may find an appetite building once again.
Perhaps fresh seafood, or a fantastic burger is what you crave.
You may want to venture out to Bokeelia’s Lazy Flamingo for perhaps the best burger you’ve ever had or at the center of the island, there is the lovely Street Eatz and Ale, owned by Chef Reid Freeman, who prides himself on finding just the right amount of resident flavor to make you feel like a local.
If you find that what you’re craving falls more on the standard delicious side, Pine Island Pizza is also right in the center. A delicious Italian menu awaits you, with a smiling staff, who make a habit of serving up the best pizza for miles around.
If you simply love Native American style jewelry or souvenirs, you’re going to want to check out, Traders Hitching Post, in the heart of Matlacha. For a farmers market style browse, one may fancy a trip to Pine Island Tropicals or Fruitscapes to see what they’re growing. Don’t forget some of Mama Donna’s goodies, made famous by Martha Stewart.
A day of touring and meandering at will, may leave your tummy grumbling for dinner. In case you weren’t planning to walk across Matlacha Bridge to fish for your own dinner, Blue Dog Bar and Grill is a Pine Island, Matlacha favorite. Owners John Lynch and Jesse Tincher have made a habit of keeping their attentive staff happily employed, even through the recent storms. If you’d like a panorama landscape, you can take a scenic ride out to the Tarpon Lodge in Bokeelia. Owner Rob Wells keeps things running like a well-oiled machine, whether you’re there for a gourmet meal, an overnight stay, or simply to gaze at a beautiful sunset. Tarpon Lodge, is an incredible place to do all of these things and often lent to islanders with charitable intent, such as at Beacon of Hope’s Holiday House fundraiser event, each year.
There is no getting around the soulful Pine Island vibe, felt easily through the artistry, fresh seafood, and charitable nature of the island and Pine Islanders. Come and meet us!
The Perfect Cup
4548 Pine Island Rd.
283-4447
Open 7 Days
Salty Girls Island Cafe
10700 Stringfellow Rd #30
558-4912
Open Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday
Randell Research Center
13810 Waterfront Drive, Bokeelia
www.floridamuseum.ufl.edu/rrc/ or 239-283-2157
Museum of the Islands
Located in Pine Island Center, this little gem’s exhibits include shells, dolls, household items, and fishing artifacts. The museum is housed in a former library building. It opened in 1989. Museum hours are: May-October, Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday 11 a.m.-3 p.m. November-April, Tuesday-Saturday, 11 a.m.-3 p.m. and Sunday, 1-4 p.m.
More info: www.museumoftheislands.com or 239-283-1525
Address: 5728 Sesame Drive, Bokeelia
Lazy Flamingo Restaurant 3
16501-B Stringfellow Rd
283-5959
Open 7 Days
Street Eatz & Ale
5508 Avenue A
312-4697
Open Tuesday-Sunday
Pine Island Pizza
5465 Pine Island Rd.
283-7992
Open 7 Days
Traders Hitching Post
4547 Pine Island Rd C, Matlacha, FL 33993
FruitScapes
239-237-6657
12870 Stringfellow Rd, Bokeelia, FL 33922
Pine Island Tropicals
12870 Stringfellow Rd, Bokeelia, FL 33922
Blue Dog Bar and Grill
4597 Pine Island Rd.
558-4970
Open Tuesday-Saturday
Tarpon Lodge and Restaurant
13771 Waterfront Drive in Pineland. Open daily II:30 a.m. – 9 p.m. Come by boat or car: N 26.39.562 W 82.9.180. 239-283-3999
Great Places To Eat
Matlacha
Miceli’s Waterfront Restaurant
3930 Pine Island Rd.
282-8233
Open 7 Days
The Perfect Cup
4548 Pine Island Rd.
283-4447
Open 7 Days
That BBQ Place
4590 Pine Island Rd.
312-8557
Open 7 Days
Blue Dog Bar & Grill
4597 Pine Island Rd.
558-4970
Open Tuesday-Saturday
CW Fudge Factory, LLC
4548 Pine Island Rd
283-9911
Open 7 Days
Yucatan
Waterfront Bar & Grill
4875 Pine Island Rd.
Matlacha 283-0113
Sun-Thur 11am-9pm
Fri & Sat 11am-10pm
CENTER
Pine Island Pizza
5465 Pine Island Rd.
283-7992
Open 7 Days
Street Eatz & Ale
5508 Avenue A
312-4697
Open Tuesday-Sunday
Tacos El Viejon Food Truck
5476 Avenue A
470-5830
Open Tuesday-Saturday
Salty Girls Island Cafe
10700 Stringfellow Rd #30
558-4912
Open Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday
Spots Ice Cream, Crepes & Sauces
10700 Stringfellow Rd. #80
966-4036
Open Monday-Saturday
The Eagle’s Nest Restaurant
10880 Stringfellow Rd
558-5577
Open Sunday, Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday
Danny’s Cuban Pizza
10493 Stringfellow Rd.
282-0168
Open Monday-Saturday
ST JAMES CITY
Pine Island Getaway Cafe
5281 Doug Taylor Circle
283-3602
Open Tuesday- Sunday
The Frozen Flip Flop
10191 Stringfellow Rd
616 516-6118
Open 7 Days
Domino’s Pizza
9860 Stringfellow Rd
283-8030
Open 7 Days
China Garden III
9846 Stringfellow Rd
283-8891
Open 7 Days
Froggy’s Bar & Grill
3620 Stringfellow Rd
283-3773
Open 7 Days
Marker 3 Coastal Cantina
3421 Stringfellow Rd
966-4064
Open 7 Days
Low Key Tiki
3135 Stringfellow Rd
282-8454
Open 7 Days
Phuzzy’s Boat Shack
3051 Stringfellow Rd
283-5555
Open 7 Days
The Waterfront Restaurant
& Marina
2131 Oleander St
283-0592
Open Monday-Saturday
PINELAND
Tarpon Lodge & Restaurant
13771 Waterfront Drive
283-3999
Open 7 Days
Tarpon Lodge & Restaurant offers a tranquil getaway steeped in “Old Florida” tradition and is famous for its acclaimed dining and unparalleled inshore and coastal fishing in an “island casual” atmosphere.
They are located at 13771 Waterfront Drive in Pineland. They are open daily II :30 a.m. – 9 p.m. Come by boat or car: N 26.39.562 W 82.9.180. 239-283-3999
BOKEELIA
Lazy Flamingo Restaurant 3
16501-B Stringfellow Rd
283-5959
Open 7 Days
Kickstands Bar & Grill
10251 Stringfellow Rd.
St James City, FL
Sun- 11am-4pm
Mon-Thur 11am-8pm
Fri & Sat 11am-10pm
579-0532
Jug Creek Marina & Fish House
16498 Tortuga St.
Bokeelia
283-3331
Tues-Sat 7AM- 10PM
Sun & Mon 7AM-6PM
Places To Go And Learn Something New
Randell Research Center
Visitors can tour this internationally significant site and learn about Calusa culture and their environment. The book store is now open 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., Monday-Saturday. The Calusa Heritage Trail is open daily for self-guided visits from sunup to sundown. Restrooms, book and gift shop, and classroom are open Monday-Saturday from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. Guided tours are available by special request for family groups, with COVID protocols, dependent on guide availability. To request a guided tour, call the RRC.
More info: www.floridamuseum.ufl.edu/rrc/ or 239-283-2157
Address: 13810 Waterfront Drive, Bokeelia
Museum of the Islands
Located in Pine Island Center, this little gem’s exhibits include shells, dolls, household items, and fishing artifacts. The museum is housed in a former library building. It opened in 1989. Museum hours are: May-October, Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday 11 a.m.-3 p.m. November-April, Tuesday-Saturday, 11 a.m.-3 p.m. and Sunday, 1-4 p.m.
More info: www.museumoftheislands.com or 239-283-1525
Address: 5728 Sesame Drive, Bokeelia
Pine Island Tropicals
This tropical plant nursery and outdoor farmers market specializes in organically grown plants and vegetables. Frequent visits to the nursery reveal the seasonality of the fruits and vegetables; therefore not all of the produce is available year round. They continually do research and development of different plant cultivars to further not only their education but enhance the wide varieties they offer.
More info: https://pineislandtropicals.com or 239-283-4874
Address: 12870 Stringfellow Road, Bokeelia
More Places To Go
GALLERIES
If artwork is on your radar, you may enjoy a visit to what Pine Island has to offer:
Bokeelia Art Gallery: Hours are seasonal and subject to change. This unique Art Gallery set in beautiful Charlotte Harbor features many local painters, pottery, glass and jewelry.
More info: www.bokeeliaartgallery.com or 239-738-5280
Address: 8315 Main Street, Bokeelia